Fragility models for industrial equipment subjected to natural hazards

May 15, 2025·
Oreste S. Bursi
,
Hafiz Liaqat Ali
Chiara Nardin
Chiara Nardin
,
Marco Broccardo
,
Gianluca Quinci
,
Fabrizio Paolacci
,
Luca Caracoglia
· 2 min read
from the article
Abstract
This paper presents a probabilistic assessment of seismic-induced, slosh-driven leakage in broad, single-deck floating roof storage tanks, a key concern for NaTech accidents in refineries. By analyzing a case study tank (86m diameter) using finite element (FE) models, the study evaluates failure mechanisms in seals and roof structures to derive fragility curves for leakage.
Type
Publication
Fragility models for industrial equipment subjected to natural hazards
publication
Abstract

Large cylindrical storage tanks are widely utilised in petrochemical plants to store different liquid materials, e.g., crude oil. However, these structures are revealed to be especially vulnerable in case of a natural event like an earthquake or tsunami. Damage to these tanks, indeed, can lead to technology accidents (also known as NaTech), like a spill of dangerous materials or waste of filling, typically through failed sealings. To address the challenges of leakage modelling, fragility models associated to leakage due to seismic loading conditions of large cylindrical storage tanks, specifically a broad tank endowed with a single-deck floating roof, are studied. In particular, this paper aims to utilise a probabilistic model to evaluate fragility curves associated with leakage due to slosh-induced damage of single-deck floating roofs and/or seals of broad tanks. The assessment of failure mechanisms and leakage of pantograph-type mechanical seals is considered by means of local FE models. In addition, refined FE models of broad tanks with floating roofs are considered too. Specifically, a broad tank TK-59 endowed with an 86 m diameter and a 22 m height storing crude oil was selected and investigated as an industrial case study. Finally, fragility functions are derived and commented upon for the most relevant limit states associated with leakage.

Tip

Click the Cite button above to copy .bib publication metadata into your notes.
or directly download here either the bibtex version: Download BibTeX or the plain text one: Download Plain.txt

Chiara Nardin
Authors
MSCA PostDoc at ETH Zurich (Switzerland) and UniTn (Italy)
Structural engineer and MSCA fellow working on seismic risk, fragility modelling, and uncertainty quantification for complex industrial systems at ETH Zurich and the University of Trento.
Authors
Associate Professor at University of Trento (Italy)